📰 The Gutter Report: Acquitted of Murder, Still Sentenced for Survival
The Staten Island case of Abdul Olasupo shows the fine line between self-defense, justice, and punishment.
The Courtroom Twist
Abdul Olasupo, 27, stood in front of a Staten Island judge this week with two truths hanging over him: he was acquitted of murder, but he would not walk free.
A jury cleared him in the 2020 Holland Deli shooting death of Kaseem Scott, agreeing that Olasupo acted in self-defense. But the gun he used—the very weapon that saved him—landed him a six-year prison sentence for criminal possession.
“In my 35 years, I have never had a client as respectful and good to not only me, but to court staff and officers,” said his attorney Mario Gallucci, urging leniency. Prosecutors pushed for the maximum 15 years, arguing Olasupo recklessly brought a loaded gun into a crowded deli. The judge cut down the middle.
⚖️ Abdul Olasupo listens as the judge hands down his fate—acquitted of murder, but not spared prison time.
The Scene of the Shooting
The tragedy traces back to the Holland Deli on Staten Island, a corner store already etched with the grit of street survival. It was here that an argument escalated, and shots rang out, leaving Kaseem Scott dead.
🏚️ The Holland Deli, crime scene taped off after the 2020 shooting that changed two families forever.
The Day of the Incident
Surveillance cameras caught Olasupo inside the deli on that fateful day, masked up and moving like any other customer. Moments later, the confrontation would turn deadly.
🎥 Abdul Olasupo inside the Holland Deli just before the fatal encounter.
The Human Cost
For Scott’s family, the acquittal feels like a second wound. His mother still clutches memories of a son lost too soon, forced to sit in court while the man who took his life was spared a murder conviction.
💔 Kaseem Scott with his mother—her grief remains while the courts argue law and survival.
Bigger Than One Case
This case exposes the Staten Island contradiction: jurors acknowledge street survival sometimes leaves no choice but to shoot. Yet, the same system ensures the gun itself remains unforgivable.
It’s a story of double-edged justice—where the streets and the state both demand a price.
📺 YouTube: LFTG Radio
Not for clicks — for clarity.
Good morning and Godspeed.
— Elliott Carterr
