🗞️ The Gutter Guide to FOIL: How to Force Public Records
How regular people can legally access police, DA, and government files without a lawyer
📖 What FOIL Is (In Plain English)
New York, USA — FOIL stands for Freedom of Information Law.
It’s the law that allows any member of the public to request records from government agencies.
You don’t need:
a lawyer
media credentials
a reason
or special status
If the government created the record, paid for it, or stores it — you can request it.
FOIL is how journalists get:
police reports
body camera footage
internal emails
disciplinary files
jail records
DA communications
It’s not a loophole.
It’s the law.
🧭 Where FOIL Requests Actually Begin
🧾 The official New York State Open FOIL portal — where most public record requests actually begin.
This is the real entry point. Not courts. Not lawyers. Not journalists.
Just a public website — Open FOIL NY — where anyone can submit a request directly to a government agency.
No credentials. No special access. No middlemen.
📂 What You Can Request With FOIL
People underestimate this part.
You can FOIL:
Police
arrest reports
incident reports
use-of-force reports
body cam footage
disciplinary records
internal memos
radio transmissions
Prosecutors (DA)
communications about a case
charging memos
internal emails
cooperation agreements (if not sealed)
plea discussions
Jails / Prisons
medical logs
visitation records
grievances
incident reports
death investigations
Cities & Agencies
emails
budgets
overtime logs
contracts
complaints
audit reports
If it exists on a government server, it’s probably FOILable.
🧑🏽💼 Step 1: Identify the Correct Agency
FOIL requests go to whoever holds the record, not the court.
Examples:
NYPD records → NYPD Legal Bureau
DA files → District Attorney’s Office
Prison records → Department of Corrections
City emails → City Clerk or Mayor’s Office
If you send it to the wrong place, they’ll just forward or deny it.
✍🏾 Step 2: Write the Request (This Is Where Most People Mess Up)
FOIL is not about being emotional.
It’s about being specific and boring.
Bad request:
“All records about police corruption in Brooklyn.”
Good request:
“All incident reports, arrest records, internal memoranda, and disciplinary files relating to Officer John Doe (Shield #12345) between January 1, 2022 and December 31, 2024.”
Specific names, dates, locations, report types = faster results.
No narratives.
No opinions.
No accusations.
Just records.
📬 Step 3: What an Actual FOIL Response Looks Like
📩 A real FOIL acknowledgment email from a District Attorney’s Office, confirming receipt and outlining timelines and costs. Personal information redacted.
This is what you’ll usually get first:
confirmation
tracking reference
response timeline
and potential fees
Not silence. Not vibes.
A real paper trail.
⏳ Step 4: The Timeline (This Is Your Leverage)
By law, agencies must:
acknowledge your request within 5 business days
give a projected completion date
They will often:
delay
extend
partially deny
or redact
That’s normal.
FOIL is a persistence game, not a one-click button.
🕶️ What Redactions Mean
Agencies can legally hide:
private personal info
active investigation material
confidential sources
certain internal deliberations
But they cannot hide:
entire records without reason
everything by default
or just because it’s embarrassing
Redactions are part of the process — not the end of it.
🚫 What To Do If You’re Denied
Every FOIL denial can be appealed.
An appeal:
forces a second review
creates a paper trail
increases your chances
Denials are not failures.
They’re just another step.
📰 How We Use FOIL at The Gutter Report
When we publish investigations, we often include lines like:
“The Gutter Report has submitted a FOIL request for the underlying records.”
That means:
we’re not speculating
we’re not guessing
we’re documenting
If granted, those records are published in full.
🔓 Why FOIL Changes Power Dynamics
FOIL turns:
rumors → documents
allegations → records
narratives → evidence
Once agencies know they’re being FOILed:
behavior changes
language changes
decisions change
Transparency creates accountability without shouting.
🛠️ LFTG FOIL TEMPLATES
Below are real, copy/paste FOIL templates.
Replace anything in [brackets] and keep everything else the same.
🚓 LFTG FOIL Template #1 – Police Incident Records
[DATE]
Records Access Officer
[POLICE DEPARTMENT NAME]
[DEPARTMENT ADDRESS OR EMAIL]
RE: Freedom of Information Law Request
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request access to and copies of the following records:
• All incident reports, arrest reports, investigative reports, and supplementary reports relating to the following incident:
Name(s) involved: [FULL NAME(S)]
Date of incident: [MM/DD/YYYY]
Location: [ADDRESS OR GENERAL LOCATION]
• Any use-of-force reports, internal memoranda, supervisor review documents, or disciplinary records connected to the above incident.
• Any radio transmissions, dispatch logs, or 911 call records associated with the above incident.
I request that these records be provided in electronic format. If any portion of this request is denied, please provide the specific statutory basis for each denial.
If portions of the requested records are redacted, please release all reasonably segregable non-exempt portions.
Sincerely,
[YOUR FULL NAME]
[YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS]
🎥 LFTG FOIL Template #2 – Body Camera & Surveillance Footage
[DATE]
Records Access Officer
[POLICE DEPARTMENT NAME]
[DEPARTMENT ADDRESS OR EMAIL]
RE: Freedom of Information Law Request – Body Camera and Video Footage
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request access to and copies of all video and audio recordings related to the following incident:
Name(s) involved: [FULL NAME(S)]
Date of incident: [MM/DD/YYYY]
Time window: [START TIME] to [END TIME]
Location: [ADDRESS OR GENERAL LOCATION]
This request includes, but is not limited to:
• Body-worn camera footage from all responding officers
• Dash camera footage from any police vehicles present
• Surveillance footage from precinct, holding cells, or interview rooms
• Any other audio or video recordings captured by law enforcement equipment in connection with this incident
I request that the footage be provided in electronic format.
If any portion of this request is denied, please provide the specific statutory basis for each denial.
If redactions are applied, please release all reasonably segregable non-exempt portions.
Sincerely,
[YOUR FULL NAME]
[YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS]
🧑🏻⚖️ LFTG FOIL Template #3 – District Attorney Communications
[DATE]
Records Access Officer
[COUNTY] District Attorney’s Office
[DA OFFICE ADDRESS OR EMAIL]
RE: Freedom of Information Law Request – Prosecutorial Records
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request access to and copies of the following records:
• All communications, including emails, memoranda, internal correspondence, and electronic messages, relating to the case of:
Defendant name: [FULL NAME]
Case number (if known): [CASE NUMBER]
Date(s) of case activity: [DATE RANGE]
• Any charging memoranda, internal case summaries, or prosecutorial review documents associated with the above case.
• Any communications between the District Attorney’s Office and law enforcement agencies regarding the above case.
I request that these records be provided in electronic format.
If any portion of this request is denied, please provide the specific statutory basis for each denial.
If redactions are applied, please release all reasonably segregable non-exempt portions.
Sincerely,
[YOUR FULL NAME]
[YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS]
⚖️ The Next Level: Federal Records
⚖️ PACER — the federal court system used to access indictments, motions, plea agreements, and sentencing records nationwide.
FOIL controls state and local power.
PACER controls federal power.
That’s the next guide.
🧠 The Reality Check (Important)
FOIL is not magic.
It takes:
patience
follow-ups
appeals
and sometimes months
But every serious investigation you respect —
from mainstream outlets to nonprofit journalists —
runs on this exact system.
FOIL is how truth is documented.
🗣️ Why We’re Teaching This Publicly
Because the truth shouldn’t belong only to:
lawyers
institutions
or media corporations
If a record exists about your life, your case, or your community —
you deserve to see it.
Not for clicks — for clarity.
— Elliott Carterr, LFTG Radio
📱 TikTok: @elliott_carterr ↗
📺 YouTube: @lftgradio ↗
🌐 Website: LFTGRadio.com ↗
⚖️ The Gutter Justice Project ↗
❤️ Support the work: LFTGRadio.com/donate ↗
